Laine and I went up to stay in the gold country, up in a vacation cabin by the Stanislaus National Forest. We didn't go alone. We went with a couple that we've known for a couple of years, Teri Mae and Katie. I guess we met them as friends of friends, mutual friends, something like that. Katie is an adoptee, as is Laine, and they used to walk around Lake Merritt and talk before Laine and I moved over to this part of town. We've mainly seen them at parties at their house and at games nights. They're both considerably younger than we are. They're planning to get married next year.I mean MARRIED. They've planned this whole thing with their folks coming out from Boston and Ohio. They're going to have a reception of more than one hundred people. This is getting married like straight people. Maybe this is a generational thing, but I don't have any great brief for getting married, though I definitely think that queers should be able to get married and spend a fortune on it if they want to do it. But it still seems odd to know lesbians who are doing it. Like I said, it could be generational. I've know couples, lesbian couples who have been together for ages, who would laugh at the idea of spending all this cash and time for a wedding. There would probably be some muttering about heteronormarative behavior from the ex-separatists. But the marriage isn't the issue. It was the weekend.
Oh, there were lots of problems. Katie is a person who's not easily satisfied. She's also highly competitive. Now I'm not unfamiliar with the urge to compete. I'll be the first to admit it. But games are just that, games. They're nothing to get bent out of shape about. It's great to win. It's a drag to lose. But the point of a game is the play and the company. For Katie, it's more than that. She won't play a game after she's lost at it. She needs to play games she knows she can win.
That was bad enough. I won't go into all the small ways that she let us know she was not having a good time. The thing that really got me thinking was how she treats her girlfriend, Teri Mae. If you asked them, I think they'd say that they have a butch-femme relationship. That's not all that unusual, really. Laine and I have a b-f relationship, though it's not particularly marked, meaning I'm not a hard butch and she's decidely on the tomboy side of femme. Still the category is a useful one. It sets out certain ideas about gender identity and display. But I suspect that Katie identifies as butch because she thinks of masculinity as the winning team. Certainly the active, aggressive team. She slaps her partner on the ass, grabs her, runs her hands over her tits in the quasi-public space of the four of us. I gotta say I didn't much care for it and I don't think it's being butch. I think it's being a brute.
My idea of being a butch has developed over the years. If one concedes that gender is societally determined and that certain styles and gestures are assigned to different genders, then (in some ideal world) we can choose what gendered behaviors best fit our internal pictures of ourselves. The reality, of course, is that this is not a perfect world and that the choice of gendered behaviors brings some funky socio-political baggage and a whole set of unsavory assumptions about what it means to be a woman and what it means to be a man. Choosing b-f identities in this landscape means that the best you can do is to be thoughtful and avoid the tar pits of gendered behaviors as we perform these roles to greater and lesser extents.
I have always wanted to be a gentleman. Also, truth be told, I like the way that masculine desire can be modeled as active and direct. [I guess that's agency, but I also suspect this model is an artifact of when I grew up. I don't think it's "natural" or particularly inevitable, but we make our selves up out of the available material.] The whys of this? Who knows. Maybe I shouldn't have read "The Highwayman" at a early age. There's no telling why anyone ends up with the sexuality s/he has, why certain things are erotic, why certain roles seem to fit, why some people are attractive and others aren't. I am a butch because I don't completely feel "like a girl", whatever and however that means.
But as I watched Katie this last week, I also realized that in my head being butch is connected to some default behaviors and attitudes. At one point the lights in the cabin and all the houses around there went out. There was a note about this possibility in the long post the owner had sent out, so it must happen with some frequency up there. Katie was freaked out. It turns out that she's afraid of the dark out there in the country. She started wittering about the flashlights -- there were supposed to be two , but we only found one -- about the Coleman lights -- turned out to be a bad idea, no ventilation to speak of inside -- about what PG&E had to say about when the lights would come back on. All I could think was, "What a baby!" Butches are supposed to be brave, you see. This is not to say that non-butches aren't. That's laughable. But I had this (previously) unexamined belief that once you claimed the role, there are things that you should and shouldn't do and freaking out about the dark in a well-populated part of California is one of the shouldn'ts.
Wuss.
We had a nice time in the dark, watching the fire and talking. Once the lights came back on after a couple of hours, Katie wanted to play another game. I said no thanks and went up to bed.
The picture is of the approach to Bridalveil Falls in Yosemite.